By Tim Board
Over the years, I've tried various methods to untangle Hawkman’s continuity, combining visual flowcharts, chronological character tracking, and a unifying "Hawkman Continuity Theory" that treats every conflicting reboot as part of a single continuous timeline.
Instead of dismissing DC's notorious editorial retcons (what I call the "three Cs": confusing, complicated, and convoluted), I organize them using several distinct methods:
1. The "Lives of Hawkman" Flowchart
To make sense of the character's constant reincarnations and identity swaps, I created a visual historical infographic tracing the exact lineage of the Hawks' souls.
Instead of dismissing DC's notorious editorial retcons (what I call the "three Cs": confusing, complicated, and convoluted), I organize them using several distinct methods:
1. The "Lives of Hawkman" Flowchart
To make sense of the character's constant reincarnations and identity swaps, I created a visual historical infographic tracing the exact lineage of the Hawks' souls.
Branching & Merging Paths.
The chart visually maps how Golden Age archaeologist Carter Hall and Silver Age Thanagarian cop Katar Hol existed separately, merged into the "Hawkgod" during Zero Hour, and later split back out.
Modern Reconciliations.
It accounts for later twists, such as Carter Hall briefly becoming the Dragon of Barbatos in the Dark Multiverse before reverting back, and explains how Shiera Hall's soul split so that Kendra Saunders (Hawkgirl) and Shayera Hol (Hawkwoman) can coexist today. (The Guide to the History)
2. Embracing the Space-Time Reincarnation Retcon
I actively promote the major lore fix introduced by writer Robert Venditti in 2018. (Thoughts on Venditti's Ideas)
The chart visually maps how Golden Age archaeologist Carter Hall and Silver Age Thanagarian cop Katar Hol existed separately, merged into the "Hawkgod" during Zero Hour, and later split back out.
Modern Reconciliations.
It accounts for later twists, such as Carter Hall briefly becoming the Dragon of Barbatos in the Dark Multiverse before reverting back, and explains how Shiera Hall's soul split so that Kendra Saunders (Hawkgirl) and Shayera Hol (Hawkwoman) can coexist today. (The Guide to the History)
2. Embracing the Space-Time Reincarnation Retcon
I actively promote the major lore fix introduced by writer Robert Venditti in 2018. (Thoughts on Venditti's Ideas)
Non-Linear Reincarnation.
Rather than forcing Carter Hall (Egyptian prince) and Katar Hol (Thanagarian alien) to be either the exact same person at the exact same time or total strangers, this framework establishes that Hawkman reincarnates across both time and space. (Hawkman isn't that confusing)
One Soul, Multiple Eras. Under this model, I explain how all versions—including the Golden Age hero, the Silver Age space cop, and the Hawkworld reboot's Katar Hol II—are simply different past or future lives of the same soul experiencing non-linear rebirths across different planets. (A Guide to the History of Hawkman)
3. A "Map to the Hawk Universe"
Inspired by Grant Morrison's famous Map of the Multiverse, I designed A Map to the Hawk Universe as a single-page visual reference.
Rather than forcing Carter Hall (Egyptian prince) and Katar Hol (Thanagarian alien) to be either the exact same person at the exact same time or total strangers, this framework establishes that Hawkman reincarnates across both time and space. (Hawkman isn't that confusing)
One Soul, Multiple Eras. Under this model, I explain how all versions—including the Golden Age hero, the Silver Age space cop, and the Hawkworld reboot's Katar Hol II—are simply different past or future lives of the same soul experiencing non-linear rebirths across different planets. (A Guide to the History of Hawkman)
3. A "Map to the Hawk Universe"
Inspired by Grant Morrison's famous Map of the Multiverse, I designed A Map to the Hawk Universe as a single-page visual reference.
Publication vs. Story Timeline.
The map separates real-world publishing history (listing every comic run from 1940 onward on one side) from in-universe lore.
Anchor Points. It organizes the Hawks' chaotic history around fixed constants—such as key home bases (Midway City, Chicago, St. Roch), core themes (flight and self-discovery), and the distinct eras of each creative team.
4. Separating "Clones" and Imposters
When DC editors created contradictory characters to patch plot holes—such as introducing Thanagarian spy Fel Andar in the late 1980s to explain away Justice League appearances that no longer fit the timeline—I catalog them distinctly rather than lumping them together. My guides clearly label who is wearing the wings in any given decade (Carter Hall, Katar Hol I, Fel Andar, Charley Parker, or Katar Hol II) so readers never confuse one character's storyline with another's.
The map separates real-world publishing history (listing every comic run from 1940 onward on one side) from in-universe lore.
Anchor Points. It organizes the Hawks' chaotic history around fixed constants—such as key home bases (Midway City, Chicago, St. Roch), core themes (flight and self-discovery), and the distinct eras of each creative team.
4. Separating "Clones" and Imposters
When DC editors created contradictory characters to patch plot holes—such as introducing Thanagarian spy Fel Andar in the late 1980s to explain away Justice League appearances that no longer fit the timeline—I catalog them distinctly rather than lumping them together. My guides clearly label who is wearing the wings in any given decade (Carter Hall, Katar Hol I, Fel Andar, Charley Parker, or Katar Hol II) so readers never confuse one character's storyline with another's.
I put everything together in this one article titled "The Complete Guide to the History of Hawkman and Hawkgirl" so check it out!
.png)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Feel free to comment!